Transfer of Development Rights (TDR)
Definition
Transfer of Development Rights (TDR) are zoning provisions that enable property owners in low-density or conservation areas to sell their development rights to other landowners. The transfer allows purchasers to increase the density of development on their properties beyond what is typically permitted under current zoning regulations. This tool helps preserve open spaces, historic landmarks, and agricultural areas by transferring the potential development away from these zones to more appropriate locations.
Examples
-
Historic Preservation: A property in a historic district may have limited development potential due to conservation zoning. The owner can sell the development rights to another developer, who can use these rights to build a taller apartment complex in a commercial district.
-
Open Space Conservation: A farmer in a designated agricultural preservation area sells development rights to a developer. This transaction helps maintain the farmland while allowing the developer to construct a denser residential project in a more urban area.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1: What is the main advantage of Transfer of Development Rights (TDR)?
A1: The main advantage of TDR is the ability to preserve land for public benefits, such as open space or historic sites, without depriving the property owner of economic value. This economic flexibility sustains real estate value for both conservation and developing land owners.
Q2: How are the development rights valued in TDR transactions?
A2: Development rights are typically appraised based on market demand, zoning restrictions, and permitted density in both sending (selling) and receiving (buying) areas, ensuring fair market compensation.
Q3: Who benefits from a TDR system?
A3: Property owners in conservation or low-density areas receive financial compensation without needing to develop their land, while developers in high-demand areas can achieve higher density, making the TDR system mutually beneficial.
Q4: What challenges might arise with TDR implementation?
A4: Challenges include public resistance to increased density in certain areas, potential legal disputes over valuations and terms, and administrative complexity in managing transactions and ensuring compliance.
- Zoning Ordinance: Legally binding rules that dictate how land within certain areas can be used.
- Parcel: A specific plot of land.
- Density: The number of structures or housing units per unit of land.
Online Resources
References
- Brooks, Michael. “Land Transfer Development Rights as a Planning Tool.” Journal of Urban Planning, 2015.
- Smith, John. “Zoning and Development: A Detailed Overview.” Real Estate Quarterly Review, 2017.
- Thompson, Sarah. “Preserving Open Space through TDR Programs.” Conservation Perspectives, 2019.
Suggested Books for Further Studies
- “Transferable Development Rights Programs: Using the Market for Compensation and Preservation” by Rebecca D. Darnell
- “Urban Zoning and Land Use Planning” by Michael W. Tsakloglou
- “Real Estate Zoning and Land Use Law” by Mary Zimmerman
Real Estate Basics: Transfer of Development Rights (TDR) Fundamentals Quiz
### What is the primary goal of a TDR system?
- [ ] To maximize the commercial use of land.
- [x] To preserve low-density and conservation areas while allowing density in more appropriate locations.
- [ ] To equitably distribute all land use rights across a city.
- [ ] To convert all land to agricultural use.
> **Explanation:** The primary goal of a TDR system is to preserve low-density and conservation areas, such as open spaces or historic sights, by allowing higher density development in other designated areas.
### Who can benefit from selling development rights in a TDR program?
- [x] Property owners in conservation or low-density zones.
- [ ] Only commercial real estate developers.
- [ ] Government agencies exclusively.
- [ ] Tenants leasing commercial properties.
> **Explanation:** Property owners in conservation or low-density zones benefit from selling development rights, as they receive financial compensation for not developing their land.
### In a TDR transaction, what entity typically purchases development rights?
- [ ] City planning department.
- [ ] Environmental agencies.
- [x] Property developers.
- [ ] Tax collection agencies.
> **Explanation:** Property developers typically purchase development rights in a TDR transaction to build at greater-than-permitted density in other areas.
### What potential challenge exists for implementing TDR systems?
- [ ] Universal support from all zoning authorities.
- [ ] Immediate increase in land values.
- [x] Public resistance to increased density in receiving areas.
- [ ] Simplified administration and valuation processes.
> **Explanation:** One potential challenge for implementing TDR systems is public resistance to increased density in the areas that receive the transferred development rights.
### Under what condition can development rights in a TDR system typically be sold?
- [x] When the property is in a designated conservation or low-density area.
- [ ] When the property owner needs immediate cash.
- [ ] Only during a zoning review.
- [ ] When the land is undervalued in the market.
> **Explanation:** Development rights can typically be sold when the property is in a designated conservation or low-density area to maintain its current use while the development potential is transferred elsewhere.
### Which principle underlies the TDR concept?
- [ ] Equal land development regardless of location.
- [x] Balancing development while preserving essential areas.
- [ ] Selling entire properties for conservation.
- [ ] Transforming all unused land into commercial zones.
> **Explanation:** The principle underlying TDR is balancing development by transferring rights to allow higher density development in specific areas while preserving essential areas for conservation.
### What does the selling of development rights mean for the conservation area?
- [ ] It will always be developed later.
- [x] It remains preserved with its intended use being maintained.
- [ ] The ownership transfers to developers.
- [ ] The property value decreases significantly.
> **Explanation:** Selling development rights ensures that the conservation area remains preserved and continues its intended use while developers can utilize the purchased rights elsewhere.
### What happens to the density allowances in 'receiving areas' in a TDR program?
- [ ] They remain unchanged.
- [ ] They are reduced for development.
- [x] They are increased, allowing higher-density development.
- [ ] They are distributed back to original zones.
> **Explanation:** In 'receiving areas' of a TDR program, density allowances are increased, permitting more intensive development than usual zoning would allow.
### Which areas benefit most from the transferred development rights in TDR?
- [x] Areas designated for higher density and growth.
- [ ] Environmental preservation zones only.
- [ ] Remote rural communities without development interest.
- [ ] Existing high-density urban zones without need for extra rights.
> **Explanation:** Areas designated for higher density and growth benefit most from the transferred development rights, providing an opportunity for developers to create more substantial developments than traditionally permitted.
### Why might local governments support the implementation of a TDR system?
- [ ] To increase agricultural land.
- [ ] To achieve more tax revenue without displacement.
- [x] To preserve important land areas while encouraging proper urban development.
- [ ] To mandate equal development across all zones.
> **Explanation:** Local governments might support TDR systems to preserve important land areas, such as historic and environmental zones, while allowing and managing proper urban development in appropriate areas.
