Taking

Definition of Taking in Real Estate

Overview

“Taking” in real estate refers to two primary scenarios:

1. Acquisition of Land through Condemnation: This happens when a government entity acquires land for public use, often known as eminent domain.

   • Example: The Highway Department acquires parcels of land to build a new road. If the landowners do not agree on a price through negotiation, the government can acquire the land through condemnation.

2. Application of Police Power Restrictions: This involves legal restrictions imposed by government authorities on the use of the land that are so limiting they preclude any reasonable use, effectively constituting a ’taking’ without just compensation.

   • Example: A parcel of land is zoned strictly for agricultural use, but the owner argues the land is not suitable for farming and would be better used for housing. The owner claims this zoning is a ’taking’ without just compensation, which violates the Fourteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.

Detailed Explanation

1. Eminent Domain:

   • Condemnation: The legal process by which government agencies exercise their right of eminent domain. Landowners are usually compensated at fair market value for the property acquired.
   • Public Use: Common reasons include constructing public infrastructures like roads, schools, or utilities.

2. Police Power Restrictions:

   • Zoning Laws and Restrictions: Governments impose land use regulations to serve the public interest. However, if these regulations prohibit any reasonable use of the property, they may be challenged as a form of taking.
   • Reasonable Use Test: Courts often evaluate if the restriction leaves the landowner with any reasonable use of their property.

Examples of Taking

1. Public Infrastructure Projects:
   • A city acquires residential land through condemnation to build a new highway.
2. Environmental Zoning:
   • A local government re-zones a residential area into a wetland conservation zone, rendering the property unusable for its original intended use, leading owners to claim a taking.
3. Agricultural Zoning:
   • A parcel suitable for residential development is restricted to agricultural use only, obstructing the owner’s ability to develop the land profitably.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: What is just compensation?

A1: Just compensation is the fair market value paid to a property owner when their land is taken under eminent domain.

Q2: Can private property be taken for public use?

A2: Yes, under the power of eminent domain, private property can be taken for public use, as long as the owner is provided with just compensation.

Q3: What are the limits to police power in land use?

A3: Police power restrictions must not be so restrictive that they nullify the reasonable use of the property. If they do, they may be considered a taking requiring just compensation.

Q4: What is the legal basis for challenging a taking?

A4: Challenges can be made based on the Fifth Amendment (for federal cases) and the Fourteenth Amendment (for state cases) to the U.S. Constitution, which protect against taking without just compensation and due process respectively.

Q5: Can the determination of just compensation be disputed?

A5: Yes, property owners can dispute the government’s valuation of their property and can seek a higher compensation figure through legal proceedings.

Related Terms and Definitions

• Eminent Domain: The government’s power to take private property for public use with just compensation.
• Condemnation: The legal process by which property is taken under eminent domain.
• Police Power: The authority of government to regulate land use to promote public welfare, safety, and health.
• Zoning Laws: Regulations governing land use within particular jurisdictions.
• Inverse Condemnation: A situation where government action effectively takes property or significantly impairs its use without formal condemnation proceedings.

Online Resources

1. U.S. Department of Transportation - Eminent Domain
2. Institute for Justice - Eminent Domain Case Histories
3. Legal Information Institute - Takings Clause

References

1. U.S. Constitution, Amendment V and Amendment XIV
2. Black’s Law Dictionary
3. Government Land Acquisition Regulations

Suggested Books for Further Studies

1. “The Power of Eminent Domain” by Robert Meltz, Dwight H. Merriam, and Richard J. McMurchie - This book dives deep into the legal aspects and cases related to eminent domain.
2. “Rethinking the Fifth Amendment: Takings Jurisprudence, Property Rights, and the Future of Regulatory Action” by Michael C. Blumm and Lucas Ritchie - A comprehensive examination of the Takings Clause and its impact on property rights.
3. “Eminent Domain: A Comparative Perspective” edited by Iljoong Kim, Hojun Lee, and Ilya Somin - Provides insights into how eminent domain is applied in various jurisdictions around the world.

Real Estate Basics: Taking Fundamentals Quiz