Understanding Equity Skimming
Equity skimming is a real estate fraud scheme in which an unscrupulous investor uses deceitful means to obtain loans greater than the value of a property. Typically, the investor deceives lenders through the use of a “straw” buyer whose credit information is manipulated to secure a larger loan. The property is then rented out, but mortgage payments are not made, leading to foreclosure.
How Equity Skimming Works:
- An investor identifies a property to use for an equity skimming scheme.
- They involve a “straw” buyer, a person whose credit details are leveraged, sometimes falsified, to qualify for a significant loan.
- Once the loan surpassing the property’s value is approved, the property title is transferred to the investor.
- The property is rented out, usually to an unsuspecting tenant.
- The rental income is collected by the investor, but mortgage payments are not made.
- Eventually, the property goes into foreclosure, resulting in increased negative equity.
Examples of Equity Skimming:
-
Example 1:
A fraudulent investor pays John, a “straw” buyer, to use his personal credit score for a property loan application. The investor provides fake employment and income documents to secure a $300,000 loan for a property actually worth $200,000. John transfers the title to the investor after closing, and the investor rents the property. However, no mortgage payments are made, and the property enters foreclosure with increased negative equity.
-
Example 2:
Investor Jane tweaks the employment history and inflates the income of a friend participating as a straw buyer in order to qualify for a mortgage far more significant than the home’s genuine value. After acquisition, Jane rents out the property, collects rental income, and avoids paying the mortgage, pushing the property towards foreclosure.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1: What drives investors to engage in equity skimming?
- A1: Investors may engage in equity skimming to quickly pocket rental income without bearing the responsibility for mortgage payments, leading to increased negative equity at the cost of tenants and financial institutions.
Q2: What consequences do tenants face in an equity skimming scenario?
- A2: Tenants may face eviction once the property undergoes foreclosure. They are often unaware of the scheme, believing their rental payments contribute towards maintaining the property.
Q3: How can lenders protect themselves from equity skimming?
- A3: Lenders can mitigate risks by diligently verifying borrower’s credit, employment, and income documentation, conducting thorough property value assessments, and performing routine checks.
-
Straw Buyer: An individual used as a proxy in real estate transactions to obtain a mortgage or circumvent regulations fraudulently.
-
Mortgage Fraud: Any act perpetrated to misrepresent or omit relevant data to obtain mortgage loans unwarranted or excessive lodging benefits.
-
Negative Equity: When the outstanding balance on a property mortgage exceeds the property’s current value, usually as a result of a drop in property values or unpaid mortgage installments.
Online Resources
References
- “Mortgage Loan Fraud: Experiences with Simplified Form” - U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO)
- “The Truth About Mortgage Fraud” - National Mortgage Professional Magazine
Suggested Books for Further Study
- “Mortgage Fraud and Insider Abuse in Real Estate” by David Anderson
- “Mortgage Fraud: Protect Yourself from Schemes, Scams, & Swindles” by Jeffrey Jiang
- “Fraud 101: Techniques and Strategies for Detection” by Howard Silverstone and Michael Sheetz
Real Estate Basics: Understanding Equity Skimming Fundamentals Quiz
### What is the primary goal of an investor in an equity skimming scheme?
- [ ] To improve property value
- [ ] To pay mortgages on time
- [x] To collect rental income without paying mortgage dues
- [ ] To sell the property for a profit immediately
> **Explanation:** The main objective of an investor in an equity skimming scheme is to collect rental income while avoiding mortgage payments, leading to ultimate foreclosure and increased negative equity.
### What role does a "straw" buyer play in equity skimming?
- [ ] Performs maintenance on the rented property
- [ ] Rents property to tenants
- [ ] Efforts in retaining tenants
- [x] Provides credit information to obtain an inflated loan
> **Explanation:** A "straw" buyer's credit information is exploited (often falsified) by the investor to secure a loan exceeding the property's value in an equity skimming setup.
### Why might a tenant be particularly vulnerable in an equity skimming scenario?
- [x] They can be unexpectedly evicted when the property forecloses
- [ ] They always receive compensation from the investors
- [ ] They have nothing to lose as they are renting
- [ ] They can reapply for the mortgage
> **Explanation:** Tenants often face sudden eviction when the property forecloses due to unpaid mortgages, as most tenants are unaware of the equity skimming being carried out.
### What major risk do lenders face due to equity skimming?
- [ ] Having to reinvest in property upgrades
- [x] Loans default due to non-payment, leading to financial loss
- [ ] Achievement of higher interest rates
- [ ] Recovery of the loan amount
> **Explanation:** Lenders face the risk of substantial financial loss as loans default due to the investor’s failure to make mortgage payments in an equity skimming scheme.
### How can equity skimming contribute to a property slipping into foreclosure?
- [ ] Property increased value
- [ ] Payments stayed consistent
- [x] Non-payment of mortgage by the investor increases negative equity
- [ ] Early mortgage discharge
> **Explanation:** When an investor doesn’t make mortgage payments, this abstinence increases negative equity, leading to property foreclosure.
### What documentation misrepresentation can give rise to equity skimming?
- [ ] Dental records
- [x] Fabricated credit scores and income statements
- [ ] Residential purpose
- [ ] Ownership tax records
> **Explanation:** Falsified credit scores and income statements enable acquiring an inflated loan leading to possible equity skimming.
### Which federal agency would an investigation into equity skimming fall under but is inclusive to others as potential investigating entities?
- [ ] Department of Agriculture
- [ ] National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA)
- [x] Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI)
- [ ] Fish and Wildlife Service
> **Explanation:** While other possible agencies might intervene, the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) primarily steps in to investigate mortgage fraud and equity skimming types.
### Why is knowledge about the true property value critical in preventing equity skimming?
- [ ] To gain higher rental income
- [ ] To sell it quicker
- [x] To deter inflated mortgage collection under false improvement
- [ ] To limit tenant availability
> **Explanation:** Confirming the true value prevents granting inflated mortgages, deterring the crux basis equity skimming operates on.
### In a proper financial conduct, who must abstain from constructing and endorsing fraud?
- [x] Investors
- [ ] Tenants alone
- [ ] Rent collectors
- [ ] Home insurance sellers
> **Explanation:** Investors primarily must avoid constructing fraudulent schemes like equity skimming and act in valid reverence to financial codes and laws.
### What affluent approach shifts in preventing financially fraudulent activities like equity skimming?
- [x] Invoking transparency, verification, tighter loan scrutiny, and stringent penalties
- [ ] Allowing freely modified income interpretations
- [ ] Avoiding credit validation inclusive pre-mortgage reform and intervention programs
- [ ] Evading higher authority-deposited filed reports
> **Explanation:** Adopting a robust verification system—including transparency, tighter scrutiny, and more substantial consequences — shifts preventative vivid bounds against growing challenges like debt-minded scams, forming deterrent precepts.
